Fun project. Would anyone actually ever run something like this in production over something like HAProxy?

This doesn't really replace something like haproxy. In the diagrams, the "real" servers that they are load balancing to are L7 load balancers like HAProxy (using https://github.com/facebook/proxygen most likely)

The problem this solves is is when you are using haproxy but need redundancy or a single server is no longer capable of handling the load and you need to scale out to 2+ servers.

You could run 4 haproxy servers and use round robin DNS to load balance between them, but as they say, this has the problem of:

> compared to DNS it doesn't need to wait for TTL to redirect traffic from failed L7 lb.

Many people likely use anycast/ECMP for this case, but that has the other issue they mention:

> compared to anycast-based solution, L4 lbs are more resilient to the networking related issues (which triggers mass ECMP reshuffle)/ enable better handling of adding/removing of L7 lbs from the pool as well as provide better support for unequal load balancing.